Skip to main content

Kartarpur Sahib: Indian agencies suspect Sikh devotees while Pakistan respects them

Image result for pics of kartarpur sahib corridor


India should understand as to how Pakistan wins over the devotees visiting Kartarpur Sahib through the visa free access corridor in six hours, the total time that the visitors spend at the shrine where Guru Nanak finally settled after long sojourns across the regions in Asia.
This is the key to the entire problem that has made the Kartarpur Sahib shrine suspect and perceived to be a security threat by India. Punjab Director General of Police Dinkar Gupta had recently made the revelation about this perception in his controversial interview in which he talked of Pakistan’s capacity to turn Sikh devotees into instant terrorists within six hours.
It may be mentioned that the police earlier questioned some devotees from Deriwal village in Gurdaspur district who had recently returned from paying obeisance at Kartarpur Sahib provoking strong reaction. The opposition took it up in the ongoing budget session of the Assembly.
Chief Minister Capt Amarinder Singh on Friday justified the police action saying it had been done on the request of the Intelligence Bureau “in the interest of national security”. He said  had the Gurdaspur police failed to cooperate with IB in the wake of security concerns expressed by the latter, he would have taken strict action against the former.
Replying to Kultar Singh Sandhwan from AAP in the Assembly, he maintained the Punjab Police had acted within permissible limits of functioning. He made it clear that his government would cooperate with central agencies in the larger interest of the nation's security, as and when required. If the police force fails to act in accordance with the established security mechanism in coordination with the central agencies, action would be taken against them, he added.
He is perfectly right so far as extending cooperation to the central agencies so far as the issues regarding national security are concerned.
The basic issue involved, however, is as to why the Sikhs continue to be suspects. It may be mentioned that one of the main reasons Pt Jawaharlal Nehru had rejected the Punjabi Suba demand while other states were being re-organised on linguistic basis was the security concern of Punjab being a border. That amounted to suspecting the Sikhs at that time. Sikh stalwart master Tara Singh had been attacked by the Congress as the Pakistani agent at one time going by the record.
The larger dimension is regarding capacity of Pakistan to win over the hearts of the Sikhs within six hours at Kartarpur Sahib. It is the treatment on the other side that is diametrically opposite.
This is from the personal experience of this writer.
Even at the cost of being repetitive, it is pertinent to mention that the behaviour by the security agencies on the Indian side borders what can be termed as rude. The devotees are frisked at two points while crossing over to Pakistan and again at two points on return.
Nothing of this sort is there on the Pakistani side. The devotees are welcomed with all the respect, and in Punjabi. The security people on the Indian side speak Hindi. This leaves a lasting impression.
The devotees experience similar love and respect from people of Pakistan at the shrine. The number of women from Pakistan from the neighbouring areas visiting the shrine is much larger than men. The shrine is developing as a tourist place.
Baba Nanak is revered by them too.
Pakistan is winning over the Sikh devotees with the weapon of love.
It is a fact that Pakistan played its subtle card  and Kartarpur Sahib corridor is part of the deeper design. However, suspecting the Sikhs won’t counter that design.
Indian agencies  would have to change perception and strategy on this sensitive issue.





Comments

Popular posts from this blog

With India pausing trade talks with Canada, Khalistan narrative assume new dimension

  With India pausing trade talks with Canada, Khalistan narrative assume new dimension Ground Zero Jagtar Singh The decades old Khalistan narrative relating to an independent Sikh state has, for the first time, impacted India’s international relations. Pakistan is in different category. Going by the media reports, India has suspended trade talks with Canada, the country that is the most sought after by the youth from Punjab, the region where the issue of Khalistan is the most vibrant. Canada, as per these reports, has “indefinitely postponed a trade mission to India scheduled for October”. Though no direct reference has been made, tension has escalated between the two countries on the issue of Khalistan. Earlier, India has been accusing neighbouring Pakistan for aiding and abetting Sikh separatists in this part of Punjab. But one can’t choose a neighbour. However, Canada is not a neighbour and hence is in a different category. But then Indian settlers abroad being act

Lacking vocal support in Punjab, globalized Khalistan narrative continues to concern India

  Lacking vocal support in Punjab, globalized Khalistan narrative continues to concern India Ground Zero Jagtar Singh Chandigarh: One of the stories associated with sidelines of G20 front-paged by the media is the meeting Prime Minister Narendra Modi had with his Canadian counterpart Justin Trudeau whose focus was intensified activities of the secessionists who happen to be migrants of Indian origin. In simple and straight terms, the issue was the activities of those demanding setting up of Khalistan in Indian Punjab. Neither the demand for Khalistan nor the narrative between India and Canada   is new. Thousands of people died in Punjab including innocents and hundreds of those killed by security forces in fake encounters in the armed struggle that got triggered with the gunning down of Nirankari chief Gurbachan Singh on April 24, 1980 in Delhi by then unknown ordinary Sikh Ranjit Singh accompanied by Kabul Singh from Damdami Taksal. This was to avenge the killing of 13 Sik

As Institutionalization of politics of polarisation produced Horror of Manipur, battle has to be ideological

  Institutionalization of politics of polarisation produces Horror of Manipur Ground Zero Jagtar Singh Who is responsible for the horror of Manipur? This question might seem ridiculous after the arrest of some perpetrators of this crime against humanity. It is not. The issue is that of the roots. There is also a reason as to why the expression of shame at the top was not unqualified. There is a reason as to why a dominant section in India is trying to unjustly legitimize horror of Manipur by citing examples of crimes against women in West Bengal, Rajasthan and some other non-BJP rules states. It is not that the country has witnessed such horror for the first time since 1947. This happened in November 1984 on the streets of the national capital that is Delhi and several other cities in the country. The victims then were the Sikhs. This happened in 2002 in Gujarat. The victims were the Muslims. At the root was politics of hate. The Congress used politics of communalizatio