Skip to main content

Distortion of Sikh Faith in films calls for systemic approach by formulating guidelines, not just jerk reaction

 





(Above three pics are self0explanatory)

Distortion of Sikh Faith in films calls for systemic approach, not just jerk reaction

Ground Zero

Jagtar Singh

Yet another instance of  distortion of Sikh Faith in a film has surfaced this week.

It is not alleged distortion but distortion going by the video of the song of the said film Yaarian 2, although the producer has tried to refute this charge.

Provoked by this distortion, the Shiromani Gurdwara Parbandhak Committee, the highest elected statutory body of the Sikhs that was constituted to voice Sikh concerns, has lodged complaint against makers of Yaarian 2.

As per the newspaper reports, seeking ban, the SGPC has approached the Union Ministry of Information and Broadcasting.

In the official statement released by the producer that has appeared in the papers, it has been denied that the actor concerned was wearing a kirpan asserting it is Khukri that is carried by the Gurkhas.

The actor who is wearing it is clean-shaven and not a Sikh.

The short-blade kirpan that the actor is carrying is in a Gatra that is worn by the Sikhs to carry this small kirpan. The Gurkhas don’t wear Gatra to carry Khukri that is also different in shape from Kirpan.

This is the issue at present that has generated controversy.

And it is not for the first time that such issue has cropped up.

It is being  made clear here that distortion of Sikh faith in films is different from lampooning of Sikh characters at times.

One has to go to the roots of this issue.

The Hindu religion is not monolithic  and there are several deities.

Moreover, nobody  objects to shooting of even romantic scenes near centres of Hindu religion and at times, even within the complex.

Remember the scene in Sholay in a village Shiva temple?

There are reasons for Sikhs raisng strong objections.

The Sikhs have made supreme sacrifices to maintain sanctity of their places of Faith. Even inch of the Golden Temple (Darbar Sahib) complex in Amritsar has blood of the Sikh martyrs. This is not the only reason.

The issue is how to address such concerns.

It is for the SGPC to take the initiative as custodian of this Faith.

Till a few years ago, even a primer educating the non-Sikhs about this religion was not available in English. One can’t say whether this basic step has been taken so far or not.

There are no dos and don’ts for the mass media. There are no guidelines in black and white for film world.

The SGPC should set up a committee of Sikh scholars to prepare the draft for this purpose. The language must be vetted so that people in film industry can understand the issues rather than using the religious terminology.

Once finalized, the guidelines should be first released in Mumbai to the film industry followed by Delhi.

In the absence of guidelines, such issues would continue to crop up.

Of course, it is not just in case of Hindu religion that liberties are taken by the film world.

A film like Da Vinci Code can’t be produced in India that concern private life of Jesus Christ.

It is pertinent to recall that earlier, some film unit had tried to shoot in the plaza in front of the main entrance of the Golden Temple.

Scenes are shot of characters worshipping pictures of the Sikh Gurus despite the fact that Sikh Faith is opposed to the idol worship.

And such violations are too frequent and are ignored even by the SGPC and other Sikh institutions.

Such distortions have creeped in at several levels.

The issue is complex but the beginning should be made by the SGPC by preparing guidelines for the film makers as the first step. It calls for systemic approach.

Lodging complaint with the police is not the answer.  It is just jerk reaction.

 


Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Sinister and deep design to divide Sikhs and Hindus in Canada needs to be exposed

  Sinister and deep design to divide Sikhs and Hindus in Canada needs to be exposed Ground Zero Jagtar Singh Chandigarh: Let us decode deeper design in what apparently seems to be deliberate distortion of facts in case of the so-called Sikh-Hindu clash in Canada to project it as confrontation between the two communities. The Indian media and the establishment gave it out as a communal conflict and attack on a Mandir, the Hindu place of worship. Let us first put the matter straight from the evidence available in the form of videos relating to every dimension of this narrative and the statements. It was neither a Sikh-Hindu clash nor an attack on the Hindu temple per se. It was a protest by the SFJ activists against the Indian consulate organizing a camp there. Such protests have been held against the consulate outside the gurdwaras too as per the record. The saner statement issued by the Hindu Federation of November 4 is very important in the interpretation of this narra...
Post a Comment
Read more

History seems to be ominously repeating itself to drive Punjab into religio-political minefield again

  History ominously repeating itself to drive Punjab into religio-political minefield again Ground Zero Jagtar Singh This headline is not rooted in some sort of pessimism. The signals are loud and clear. The onus to counter such signals is on the Punjab government. History in Punjab seems to be repeating itself to push Punjab into yet another cycle of what can be termed as the avoidable toxic situation. That cycle has now impacted even geo-political relations of India with some countries, especially Canada where the Sikhs are settled in sizeable numbers. In the context of the Sikhs as a globalized people, it is pertinent to mention that even in United Kingdom House of Commons, the representation of the Sikhs is now in double digit after the recent elections. Punjab is still impacted by the tremors of religio-political   dynamics that got triggered in 1978 with the Sikh-Nirankari clash on the Baisakhi on April 13 at Amritsar, the religious capital of the Sikhs. ...
Post a Comment
Read more

Two binaries emerging in Punjab’s multi-polar polls where last 72 hours are always crucial

  Two binaries emerging in Punjab’s multi-polar polls where last 72 hours are always crucial   Ground Zero Jagtar Singh Chandigarh, May 28: The inter-play of socio-political forces in Punjab in the run up to the June 1 Lok Sabha elections is unprecedented. This is besides that established fact that the religio-political dynamics of this state has always been different from the rest of India, even when the boundaries of this country touched the Khyber Pass connecting with Afghanistan. It is for the first time that so many main political players are in the fray independently thereby making the contest multi-polar. Then there are two other eruptions in the electoral matrix making the multi-polar contest all the more interesting, and also important for future dynamics of not only Punjab but also India as the roots of this phenomena are not in too distant a past but in not so recent period of militancy. It is after decades that Punjab is going to the polls without a...
Post a Comment
Read more