Skip to main content

Modi phenomenon can crash in case 3 farm acts are junked, at stake is also democratic resistance

 


Farmers’ survival pitted against Modi model of pro-corporate governance and divisive politics

Jagtar Singh

Ground Zero

 

The stakes are now much higher.

At stake is the survival of the farmers pitted against Prime Minister Narendra Modi phenomenon and his pro-corporate and divisive model of politico-economic discourse.

For the country, it is an opportunity to restore faith in participatory democracy.

The unprecedented mobilization on the socio-economic issue of survival of the farmers as reflected in the extensive support to the peaceful Bharat Bandh from Gurdaspur to Guwahati  poses the first serious threat to the pro-corporate and divisive model of governance that India has been subjected to under Modi since 2014.

A very interesting aspect of the situation is that the farmer wing of the Rashtriya Swayamseak Sangh that groomed Modi over the years had expressed reservations at the early stage itself about the three farm ordinances as the resistance got triggered in Punjab. This was at the time when the Akali Dal top leadership including Parkash Singh Badal, Sukhbir Singh Badal and Harsimrat Kaur Badal was stoutly defending the new farm trade model that the farmers feared to be threat to their very existence.

In case the struggle succeeds in the repeal of the three farm acts, this would amount to demolition of the Modi phenomenon. The Prime Minister has repeatedly defended these acts as pro-farmer and the need of the hour to reform the farm sector. There are no two opinions that the farm sector desperately needs reforms but the same can’t be at the very survival of the farmers. The farmers should have been consulted at various levels before introducing such drastic changes that are rather farm trade oriented and not farmer oriented that the corporates can now monopolise posing problems for the consumers too.

Going by the discussion at the last meeting of the farmer leaders with the government, agriculture minister Narendra Singh Tomar offered that the government was willing to  accommodate almost every concern raised by them in writing but for scrapping of these acts.

The farmer leaders made a vary pragmatic counter offer saying that they were not opposed to reforms per se but these same must be introduced in consultation with them. In concrete terms, they proposed that these acts should be repealed and a committee constituted including their representatives for formulating reform measures to be incorporated in the new legislation. This is the correct approach to the logjam.

But then the Modi phenomenon would crash if these acts are junked.

It seems that the survival of the Modi model of pro-corporate and divisive narrative is more crucial that the very survival of the farmers, at least in the short run.

The RSS has been working very hard to put its Hindu Rashtra stamp all over India and the way the party contested the local body polls in Hyderabad is its latest example. The success of the farm struggle has the potential to block the Hindutva juggernaut.

This divisive narrative can be confronted only by inclusive narrative that was the idea of India that evolved during the framing of the constitution after the partition in 1947. The Sangh Parivar has been targeting that very idea of inclusive India that is the foundation of every participatory democracy. Distributing gas cylinders to people irrespective of religion or similar distinctions is not the participatory democracy but just amounts to throwing some crumbs.

The Bharat Bandh has made it evident that such mobilization against the divisive narrative is possible with non-divisive issues and concerns at the centre.

The farmers are the axis around which the economy revolves and that has been proved during this pandemic. The Indian economy that has been receiving repeated hits since demonetization has survived mainly because of the farm sector. The issue of survival of the farmers  should be the concern each and every Indian in this backdrop.

This awareness seems to have been converted into massive support to the farmers cause going by the Bharat Bandh.

It is the farmer who has to be saved, not just the farming that the corporates now want to monopolise. The farmers have realized the threat to their very existence.

It is for this reason that these farm laws just be junked and a panel set up. The Modi phenomenon is not more important than the very existence of the farmers.

The farmers struggle is already getting transformed into mass movement with global attention.

What is needed is just one more push.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Damage to institution of Akal Takht symbolising Sikh sovereignty more important dimension of current crisis in Sikh domain

  Ideological Damage to Akal Takht most important dimension of Akali Crisis Ground Zero By Jagtar Singh The Sikh religio-political discourse entered a new phase on Baisakhi 2025 — the historic day on which Guru Gobind Singh, in 1699, created the Khalsa at Anandpur Sahib, completing the ideological foundation laid by Guru Nanak Dev, the founder of the Sikh faith. Significant developments emerged from the well-attended Shiromani Akali Dal (SAD) conference held at Takht Sri Damdama Sahib on April 13. It was the first major public appearance of Sukhbir Singh Badal since his re-election as party president on April 12, marking his return to the helm after a brief interregnum. Sukhbir, who first succeeded his father, Parkash Singh Badal, as party president in 2008, resumes leadership of a party long dominated by the Badal family—an influence that has spanned over three decades, the longest in the SAD’s history. For months, the religio-political landscape of Punjab has remained i...
Post a Comment
Read more

Strategic polarisation by BJP has potential to dislocate social secularism in Punjab

  Strategic polarisation by BJP has potential to dislocate social secularism in Punjab Jagtar Singh Chandigarh: Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s recent visit to Dera Sachkhand Ballan in the Doaba heartland—an area where Dalit social and religious formations wield considerable influence—has once again revived the debate on the role of deras in Punjab’s complex religio-political landscape. Punjab, a border state that has historically witnessed alternating cycles of violent and remarkably peaceful mobilisations over more than a century, continues to remain politically sensitive and socially layered. This is typical Punjab whose political discourse has invariably been dictated by the Sikh religio-political discourse, at least till recently. This dominant Panthic religio-political discourse has now got fragmented over the period, thereby yielding space to new permutations and combinations in the state’s religio-political matrix. It can safely be said that Punjab is in a flux. The ...
Post a Comment
Read more

Akal Takht intervenes to reset Sikh religio-political discourse

  Akal Takht intervenes to reset Sikh religio-political discourse Ground Zero Jagtar Singh Chandigarh, Dec 8: The Sikh religio-political domain has the tendency to dictate religio-political discourse of Punjab whose polity is different from other regions in the country. This is the state where a national dynamic minority is in majority. This minority was the third entity in all the political negotiations leading to India’s independence. What happened in Punjab on December 2 has to be reviewed in this backdrop as this development is going to have far-reaching impact not only on the future of the Shiromani Akali Dal but also the political tendencies at several levels. It is pertinent to mention at this stage itself that the Sikh religio-political discourse is presently affecting even India’s geo-politics, especially in the American sub-continent in the context of the activities of a section of the Sikh Diaspora. December 2 was unprecedented in the history of more than a c...
Post a Comment
Read more